Less on show: social networks are moving likes, saves and blocks out of public view
All of the major platforms have, with varying degrees of openness, reduced the amount of information publicly available about what others are doing. The number of likes, follows and general approvals of any given post have traditionally been very visible. All that started to change several years ago, and continues to this day.
| Signal on X | Who can see it now | Since |
|---|---|---|
| Which posts you liked | Only you | June 2024 |
| Who liked a post | Only the author; others see the count | June 2024 |
| What you bookmarked | Only you | Always |
| Who you muted, and which words | Only you | Always |
| Who you blocked | You; the blocked account finds out if it visits your profile | Block rules changed in November 2024 |
| What appears in your For you view | Only you | By design |
| Reposts and replies | Everyone | Unchanged |
Likes
As mentioned earlier, all profiles on X used to allow others to view which tweets its owner had liked. From June 2024, however, these became visible only to the person and the person who authored the tweet. As with Instagram (which introduced a similar feature a while ago), no other person will know, although the total number will continue to be shown. So it seems increasingly acceptable for only the person who likes a tweet, and possibly the person who wrote it, to know. I would expect the same to apply to re-tweets.
Saves
I would also expect this trend to apply to bookmarked tweets. Of course no one can ever know whether you bookmark a tweet, and you will never know which tweets others have bookmarked. It would appear that with the increased use of bookmarks, as likes become less visible to others, there would be fewer reasons to like tweets. As a result there would be fewer likes, and more bookmarks and re-tweets. Only re-tweeting would signal to others that you agreed with a particular message.
Mute and block
Other actions such as muting and blocking would also be known only to the person taking the action. Any tweets from a muted user would simply be filtered out, and there would be no way of knowing if any given user had muted you. The same applies to words you wish to filter out. Even blocking would now only prevent replies, likes, re-tweets, follows and private messages. The person blocked would be able to view all your public tweets. Clearly the effect of most of these options would be apparent only to yourself.
The feed
Of course your timeline could also be very different to anyone elses. Assuming you viewed Following, all tweets from the users you followed would be displayed, and presumably in some predictable order. Assuming you viewed For You, however, the tweets displayed would be specific to you, determined by some unknown algorithm. So 2 people could be following exactly the same set of users, but see very different tweets. Presumably this is one of the largest areas of private information available on the platform, as there would be very little overlap between 2 different peoples timelines. This would presumably extend to all users of the platform, so there would be millions of different private views.
Why it is happening
So there are clearly 2 motivations behind this increased privacy. Firstly, it would be hoped that users would be more forthcoming, and more willing to like or re-tweet if they knew no one else could see. Secondly, the platform would benefit greatly by knowing the true interests of its users. It is clear that the more the platform knows about its users interests, the greater the chance it has of keeping them engaged.
What users gain
Clearly there are many positives to these changes for users. As mentioned previously you would be under less pressure to act in a particular way, knowing no one else would be aware. So you may be more comfortable to like a tweet knowing your boss wouldn’t see, or to mute someone in your family, or to bookmark some information relating to a health concern. It’s not surprising, therefore, that very few people would wish to return to the previous state of affairs.
What is lost
Many people who relied upon these signals to learn about others would suffer. One could tell something about someone by looking at all of their likes. Academics, reporters and others could see how a topic spread. Businesses could determine who among their clients liked a competitor. Most of these uses no longer exist. Only what people say publicly and share is visible. Hence much more thoughtful.
Three adjustments for people who post for work
Any professional making posts should consider the following. Firstly, cease attempting to demonstrate popularity of a post to others. While it will still display how many have liked it, there is no way to verify who they are and audiences are sceptical. Replying to, or sharing, another person’s post is much more telling as one’s identity is known. Secondly, base your assessment on a person’s writings. View their posts, replies, etc., before deciding whether to follow them, collaborate with them or employ them. As mentioned, you won’t be able to see what they have liked. Finally, you won’t know if any given post has appeared in the For You section or what prompted this. So review your analytics periodically.
| Old habit | What to do now |
|---|---|
| Pointing to a like count as proof | Point to replies and reposts, which carry names |
| Reading a stranger’s likes before following | Read their posts and replies |
| Assuming followers all saw the same post | Check your own analytics over several weeks |
| Liking to show support publicly | Repost or reply |
Where it goes next
Clearly it is difficult to foresee precisely how it will evolve. However, over a number of years now and on various platforms, there continues to be a reduction in information available to others and an increasing amount of personalised content. It would be sensible for anyone wishing to make use of social media to assume this pattern will continue, with less and less available publicly.